SPEC Kit 346: Scholarly Output Assessment Activities · 101
UNIVERSITY OF PITTSBURGH
Using Bibliometric (Publication and Citation) Indicators to Demonstrate Impact (slides)
http://d-scholarship.pitt.edu/20647/1/Bibliometrics_Seminar_Feb2014_DSchol.ppt
4/29/15�
1�
USING BIBLIOMETRIC (PUBLICATION AND CITATION)
INDICATORS TO DEMONSTRATE IMPACT
Robin Kear and Berenika M. Webster
ULS Lunch and Learn
February 20, 2014
1
�
OUTLINE
K Evolution of Metrics; Caveats�
K Current Sources of Metrics�
K Library can assist faculty with understanding:�
K individual impact�
K journal impact�
K institutional impact�
K Discussion
EARLY METRICS
1 Counting outputs �
1 3rd century BC – number of items held in the Great Library of Alexandria was 490,000�
1 In 1837 Royal Library in Paris held 620,000 and public libraries in the US – 1,294,000�
1 In 1841 numbers of volumes in libraries were normalized by population (Munich 750
volumes per 100 people; Florence – 313; Paris – 143 and London – 20) �
1 Counting usage, incl. collections development�
K In 1874 an article claimed that in American public libraries ¾ of the circulation was
“sensational food”==B9.?I0A6;.;1;9F¼ to “literary food” �
K 1927 Gross and Gross from Pomona College analyzed references in one volume of Jln
of Am Chem Soc and recommended a list of 22 journals (12 non-English) to become a
core of the college chemistry collection
EARLY METRICS
�
K "2.@B?6;4@062;A6I0D?83?02.;16A@6:=.0A
;@062;A6I012C29=:2;A(Cattel,1906)
K Measuring civilizational development through
volume of published outputs (Humle, 1923)
K Mapping scholarly disciplines by analyzing
citation patterns (Fussler, 1948)
K H"2.@B?6;4@062;02LB@6;4@062;A6I0A9@
(DeSolla Price, 1963)
EVOLUTION OF METRICS
B42;2.?I291@“association �
of ideas index”�
1 Information retrieval�
1 9.@@6I0.A6;.;16;12E6;4�
EVOLUTION OF METRICS
Sociology of science and the Matthew effect�
(Matthew xiii.7)
�
For whosoever hath, to him
shall be given, and he shall
have more abundance: but
whosoever hath not, from
him shall be taken away
even that he hath �
�